This post was conceived with the help of The Big Push for Midwives, which also helped out with its delivery.
Private Membership Associations
Earlier this year, news articles reported on criminal actions against community (out-of-hospital) midwives in Indiana and Nebraska following infant deaths. More recently, the work of one midwife in Minnesota was highlighted; she was not under state investigation, nor were any bad birth outcomes mentioned.
What do these three midwives have in common? They all have formed Private Membership Associations (PMAs), legal instruments that claim to exempt their members from state regulation. Clients of these midwives become members of PMAs, which supposedly allow them to essentially contract out of state governance of their midwives.
However, in reality it doesn’t work that way. States with licensing regimes, like Indiana, allow their state midwifery boards to issue complaints against negligent midwives, whether the midwives have obtained licenses or not. Because the unlicensed practice of a profession is a criminal offense, these complaints are often conveyed to the state attorney general’s office, after which charges may be filed against the midwife. In states that do not offer licensing of community midwives, like Nebraska, the route to criminal charges is much more direct: reports of a bad outcome may land immediately on the county prosecutor’s desk.
The cartoon above is our take on why PMAs are a bad idea, and why midwife licensing is a good idea. Many people these days mistrust government – and who can blame them? But remember: the answer to bad law isn’t no law; the answer to bad law is good law.
An aside about PMAs, birth outcomes, and midwife arrests
When midwives are arrested after a newborn or maternal demise, as in the news articles linked above, some readers find it tempting to channel their lock-em-up-and-throw-away-the-key rage right at them. Allow us to take this opportunity to remark that physicians rarely face arrest when their patients die. Furthermore, this post is in no way a comment about the outcomes in any of the births in the news articles or on the level of skill and training possessed by the midwives who attended those births. Midwives are often blamed for bad birth outcomes no matter what their license status, training, skill, or education. The shamefully high infant and maternal mortality rates associated with conventional hospital-based care, on the other hand, is just starting to be questioned.
All images are shared under a Creative Commons license, unless otherwise noted. Where required by license, changes to the image are noted.
- Venetian vampire is by LunarSeaArt.
- Garlic and background is by zandy126.
- Cat (evil) eyes is by Stephen Henning.
- Cradle is from freestocks.org.
- Bow ribbon clip art is by ocal.
- The paneled door, south front facade, is by Jack Boucher. The image is in the public domain.
- Hikers are by aleksandr Ovchinnikov.
- The broom is by JJuni.
- The lawyer researching in the law library is by gallery 7star.
- The Fortress Midwifery building is really part of the
Golubac Fortress in the Đerdap national park in Serbia.The image is from Max Pixel and is in the public domain.
- The Viking longboat is by Midnightblueowl. We added the torch by Kiernax.
- The bomber is by U.S. Air Force. The image is in the public domain.
- The helicopter is by Capt. Richard Barker. The image is in the public domain.
- The sailing ship is a photograph of Cannon Fired by Willem van de Velde the Younger, 1707. The photo is by the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam and is in the public domain.
- The Virginia-class attack submarine is by Owly K. The photo is in the public domain.
- The cannon is from a photo of the Saint Kitts – Brimstone Hill Fortress, taken by Martin Falbisoner.
- The background is a photo of the Ballroom at Rideau Hall, Ottawa, by Dennis Jarvis. We cropped the image, edited out some chairs along the back wall, and swapped the portrait of Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II with one of Martha Ballard, midwife.
- The lectern is from “WikiData Presentation 2018,” by Michelle Nitto.
- The pink house in the poster is of Zemīte Manor, by J. Sedols.
- The projector screen is from Max Pixel.
- The midwife/breastfeeding mother is by Renoir. She is wearing an oxytocin necklace. Her bag is from Needpix.com. It is filled with a water bottle by wraithrune, a yoga mat by MikesPhotos, and a sweet little stuffed cow by OpenClipart-Vectors.
- The Big Push for Midwives logo is from The Big Push for Midwives! You should check them out!
- Finally, the speaker at the lectern is Cynthia Jackson, CPM, LM, of Michigan: midwife extraordinaire and unparalleled portrait subject. The photo is used with permission. Ms. Jackson runs Sacred Rose Birthing Service and is a founder of the Mosaic Midwifery Collective, both in Detroit.